I handle single-family and multi-family sales, and with a two-family the paperwork can make or break the deal. Merrick and Bellmore are unincorporated hamlets, so the Town of Hempstead keeps the building records and issues the rental permits. Here's what I look at, whether you're buying or selling.
- Confirm the Town's records show a legal two-family before you sign.
- The Town rental permit doesn't transfer. A buyer who will rent needs a new one.
- Tenants' security deposits pass to the buyer at closing, with notice to the tenants.
- A buyer steps into the seller's place under existing leases.
- The seller pays the state transfer tax; the buyer pays the 1% mansion tax at $1 million and up.
1. Confirm it's a legal two-family
The Town of Hempstead Building Department keeps the certificates of occupancy and permit history for homes in Merrick and Bellmore. Its online permit center has a certificates section for searching a property's history, and an official permit search sheet costs $40 per location (include the section, block and lot). Check that the certificate of occupancy matches how the house is actually used, and that the second unit and any additions have permits. Homes inside an incorporated village use that village's building department instead.
2. The Town rental permit
The Town of Hempstead requires a rental permit for rental dwelling units (Chapter 99). Per the Town's registration form, the owner applies, the application fee is $300 (applied toward the permit), the permit is $500 for the first unit plus $200 for each additional unit, and it runs for two years. The application asks for a copy of the certificate of occupancy and the building permits on the property. Two points matter at a sale: rental permits are nontransferable, so a buyer who will rent needs a new one, and rentals of less than 28 days aren't permitted. Confirm current fees with the Town before you count on them.
3. Security deposits
In New York a security deposit can't exceed one month's rent, and at move-out the landlord has 14 days to return it with an itemized statement of anything kept (GOL § 7-108). When the house is sold, the seller turns the deposits over to the buyer at closing or within five days and notifies each tenant by registered or certified mail; from then on the buyer is responsible for returning them (GOL § 7-105).
4. Existing leases
New York law lets the new owner step into the seller's place under existing leases (RPL § 223). If you plan to move into a unit that's rented now, ask your attorney how the current lease affects your timing before you sign.
5. What sellers should have ready
In practice, buyers' attorneys ask to see every current lease, what each unit pays, and a list of the tenants' security deposits, along with the certificate of occupancy and permits. Having them ready before you list keeps the contract stage short. I help sellers pull it together.
6. Transfer taxes
New York's real estate transfer tax is $2 for every $500 of the price, paid by the seller. On one-, two- and three-family homes selling for $1 million or more, the buyer also pays the mansion tax of 1% of the price.
Thinking about buying or selling a two-family? Get a free valuation or ask me about a specific property.
General information, not legal or tax advice. Your attorney reviews the contract, leases and records.

Buying · 3 min readBuying on the water? What to check first.